Five Minute Friday: Broken and Beautiful

Show Me Your Ears

Show Me Your Ears

I am not so sure I like what I see today.
Sags under the eyes, a mass of hair twisted into a low ponytail,
my ears completely exposed.

It took me two years before I’d let this much of myself show.
My bottle blonde hair
and palette of cosmetics
usually help me blend in with the other moms
who drive their children to sporting events
on a warm summer afternoon.
I turn the wheel,
hoping to avoid the stark reflection
that stares back in the rearview mirror.

A profile of me with the low ponytail says it all:
There is something different about me.
I am wearing hearing aids.

The chatty crowd becomes a little more subdued
(at least I imagine that it does)
as I walk past them with my behind-the-ear hearing aids
in full view.
This is the first time these moms
with their casual T-ball attire
have seen me with my hair pulled back.

As a child, I walked up to complete strangers
and introduced myself just to make them smile.
How can I face these moms now
who usually see me as I want them to,
an extrovert who likes jumping into their conversations
with a gracious nod
as if I’ve heard every word they said?

“By his stripes we are healed,”
writes ancient prophet Isaiah.
“Only when we accept the truth of our brokenness can we be healed,”
reads my latest journal entry.

How could God allow this to happen
to a young body;
progressive hearing loss
on a seemingly healthy body?

I force myself to
face the mirror,
face the moms and their polite stares,
face the cruel reality that has a surprising hint of beauty behind it.

This is who I am.
I am slowly going deaf.
This was meant to happen,
to help me hear beyond what comes through
flawed ears.
This has made me different.

My heart has cracked open
and now it can hear
that it didn’t hear before.


Join Lipreading Mom’s Show Me Your Ears Campaign

Have you ever felt “broken”?
Please share your comments below.

Five Minute Friday


23 thoughts on “Five Minute Friday: Broken and Beautiful

  1. Shanna, dear one… I hope your hours and days of hoping to help everyone with a hear aide feel confident. As I read your message this morning, this part SHOUTED at me (at least I imagine that it does) That shows YOUR true wisdom. Do you know, as a NON-hearing aide person, when I see someone with one or two aides, I notice, BRIEFLY, then silently thank God for providing such help for those who need it. Me, I need lots of other things…like HOW TO GET YOUNGER!!! =) YOU ARE WONDERFUL. I was surprised when I went to respond on your website and saw your picture of OTHERS with hearing aides. I had no idea that caused so much frustration for those wearing them.

    Keep doing what you are doing, dear one. I just learned something new from you AGAIN!! LOVE AND Hugs…. G-Ma Sally D.

  2. OMG! I love your writing!! I wish you had been blogging twenty years ago. I would have copied and stuck it on my fridge! I didn’t have your daring back then. The world was a little less tolerant. The ADA so new. Most of my peers grew up in a time when disabilities were hidden away. The day I exposed my ears I felt so liberated. 🙂

  3. Hi Shanna,

    I normally deeply appreciate your blogging, and mostly do today, but I am going to pick a bone with you over one word. Just one.


    You are NOT broken. You are hard of hearing. Your ears are not broken. They are doing what they are programmed to do by your body. They are functioning in the way your body and your higher power intended. You are experiencing a journey that enriches you and others through your sharing of your experiences. If you had perfect hearing, you would not be writing or blogging about something this meaningful. You have been gifted, despite how you may feel.

    Helen Keller was not broken because she was deaf/blind. She had struggles and barriers to overcome, and yet, she has been a beacon to the world for those who are deaf/blind. Helen Keller was a gift to the world – a gift from Higher Power (HP). She and you – are not – and never were “broken.”

    We make the D/deaf and Hard of Hearing feel “broken,” or “impaired” or in some way lesser than “normal people.” I refer to this as being the children of some sort of lesser god.

    The worst thing about being Hard of Hearing or deaf/Deaf is social isolation. We are socially isolated because we are ashamed of hearing loss because we’ve been taught it is a bad thing. Our kids and relatives may bully and ridicule us – because society sees us as lesser beings. We are socially isolated because we don’t tell others what we need, insist on what we need. God knows we’d fight for our kids to have what they need if they are brilliant or need glasses, or are in some way different than the mainstream. We don’t consider our children “broken” if they need glasses or they have a different style of learning, but to often we see ourselves as broken.

    In fact, most deaf/Deaf are master communicators. We observe everything around us. We are masters of non-verbal communication. Many of the oral high-functioning deaf are bilingual fully in both English and ASL – and sometimes SEE and pidgin ASL as well. How many people to we know who speak English, Italian, Spanish, and Portuguese? It is largely the same – these are all a variety of Romance Languages.

    Some, like you, do a lot of lip reading. The best lip readers are fortunate to get 30% of the spoken language because many sounds are made in the middle and back of the mouth. Add an unfamiliar accent and we’re dead in the water – it is like a hearing person trying to translate a thick Cockney accent when only knowing the flat Nebraska accent of America. The hearing person is not “broken,” they are experiencing something that they would have to learn to understand.

    I have worked with small groups of people in social work. They may be born to a family speaking Yu’pik and yet the child may end up speaking English in school and Yu’pik at home – then leave home and leave the language, never to return to that language except to speak to their parents or grandparents. I did this with my grandmother who spoke German. You don’t want to know what parts of German speech I remember ;).

    The Deaf Community is the only language and community we enter and never leave again. There is no such thing as learning to hear again. Even with a cochlear implant or hearing aids or even through dangerous implants into the hearing centers in the brain stem, we will never be “hearing.” We will be Hard of Hearing at best. We still are not “broken.” We are different, but we are just as vital and capable as any hearing person. We may end up speaking ASL, SEE or pidgin ASL, but we are not broken. It is as if we speak another language now – we’ve moved from the “mother tongue” of English to the new language out in the world.

    You are a leader, not a broken person. You are beautiful with or without your hearing aids. You have value because of who you are – with lower than normal hearing. You are a teacher, a role model, an inspiration, a joy. You are complete and whole exactly as you are.

    You are just as Higher Power intended you to be. Be glad and rejoice in this. 🙂

    Happy Easter to you and yours.


    • Marsha – The word ‘broken’ has many connotations. I use this word to describe how my heart felt when I discovered there was something I couldn’t control: my hearing. But the good part is that once I accepted that I don’t control my hearing, I developed a deep sense of gratitude for what I can control: the ability to adapt.

  4. Everyone I try to use that phone and its always trying to explain to callers that don’t know me well, that my hesitations are because I’m waiting for captions.

  5. Hearing loss cuts both ways. For me, deafness has always held beauty, as I witnessed one of the most beautiful women I’ve ever known live a life of purpose with never a complaint of those things she lacked, among them, hearing. I saw beauty in everything my grandmother did, and to think that I could be like her in any way was a positive. Even sharing her deafness, I felt special, we were connected in a way that no other members of our family were.

    My hearing loss taught me so much. It made me who I am, and though I’d love to hear again, I am ever thankful for what I know because of my deafness. That’s the beauty.

    The broken comes when you’re down in that dark place, feeling vulnerable, sad, angry, and riddled with grief over a loss that has wrecked your way of living and getting along in the world. It takes time to acclimate and to learn to live with confidence again.

    Broken also comes when your third-grade son brings home an audio cassette tape his teacher recorded for you for Mother’s Day–Mrs. Kelly had each student read “Love You Forever” to their mother on tape. My family gathered around as my son gave me his gift, the tape was placed in the casette player, and I waited for it to start. I sat looking confused when no sound came, looking from one face to another as my family looked on in anticipation of my reaction. I burst into tears when I realized that the tape was playing, but I couldn’t hear it. My family surrounded me in that broken moment and I saw beauty in their love and comfort, but the sting of being broken remained for a time.

    Broken is when you’re watching an interesting story on TV about the shortage of buglers to play Taps at WWII Veteran’s funerals, complete with a demonstration of a newly developed digital bugle that requires no musical ability to play–it looks and sounds like the real thing and no one is the wiser. As the demonstration begins, I strain to hear the Taps of my memory. When there is no sound, I turn up the volume and wonder what’s wrong with the TV, trying to adjust the controls so that I can hear. Then it dawns on me, it’s not the TV that’s broken, but me, so I ask my husband to come and listen and he confirms that the sound is there. Another broken moment that hits me in the chest like a freight train. I retreat to my room to cry it out, because this is just one more incident in the chain of events that drives me to rock bottom of a progressive hearing loss that began in childhood. Once there, I’m alone in the dark and nothing seems to work anymore.

    However, there is good news… in my case, God always provides me with a release once I’ve reached the bottom. He then puts something or someone in my path to help me collect my composure and find the confidence to climb toward what’s beautiful once again.

    Here, almost at the end of my hearing ability, I take comfort in the knowledge that I have the power to transcend brokenness. That IS beautiful! ~~Michele

  6. Very heartfelt post. At first I thought you were writing about being uncomfortable about your beauty–which I could relate to with a vengeance. I never thought of anyone with hearing aids as standing out. I agree with the other comments; just because you hear less (differently) doesn’t make you less interesting, beautiful, capable.

    Thanks so much for sharing this.

    Laura Hedgecock

  7. Pingback: Beautifully Broken by Michele Linder | SayWhatClub

  8. That was a beautiful post, Shanna! The broken and beautiful idea definitely resonates with me. Nick Vujicic talks about the fact that the brokenness in our lives becomes miracles for other people so their lives can be saved from the wasting of their lives (He doesn’t say it in that many words, but I get that idea from him). You’re a miracle for someone else’s life, even through your difficulties. In this, beauty requires brokenness as a prerequisite, through which other lives are changed.

  9. You said it well. The baseball moms I had relationships with never caught on even though my hair was pulled up at those hot games. Bleachers are the hardest to keep conversations going because you most likely have people behind you talking. Sit on the bleachers and your back is towards the people talking.

  10. Great post. Captures so many emotions I’m struggling with now. Us pretty moms are not pictured in materials from the hearing aid companies! For me there is another layer which is that my school age kid is developing hearing loss too and is now aided, so this is a big motivator for me to get a grip on my own issues with being HOH.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s